Unskilled Jobs Draw Migrants, Changing Face Of Small Towns Across America

Nov 4, 2019
Originally published on November 4, 2019 8:44 pm

It is the 8 a.m. assembly at Cactus Elementary School, located on the bleak plains of the Texas Panhandle. Kids with colorful backpacks and sleepy eyes sit cross-legged on the gym floor while their principal kick-starts the day: "Good morning, Cactus Elementary!" The students crow in response.

Many of them come from poor villages in faraway lands — Central America, Somalia, Myanmar, Congo, Haiti — and they're clearly thrilled to be in school.

Principal T.J. Funderburg welcomes them all. "We need a world map to map where everybody comes from," he intones in the microphone. "But we're all here."

Over the past year, student enrollment at Cactus Elementary has surged from 300 to 400 children. The majority of new students are from Guatemala. They are part of a historic wave of more than half a million Central American parents and children who crossed the southern border, fleeing violence and poverty and asking for protection. After they were taken into custody and released to await their day in immigration court, many headed to the heartland where unskilled jobs are plentiful.

Cactus, Texas, is one of the places where America's newest immigrants are coming, and their presence has had a profound effect on the elementary school.

"What we found is the students that come in from Guatemala and Africa, they may have had some education," Funderburg says. "In Guatemala, they don't start first grade until 8 or 9 years old. And so we've really had to rethink the way that we do everything."

For instance, they need more English language teachers and they have fewer pop quizzes for the students who need lots of remedial help. The school also simply needs more space.

On Tuesday, voters will decide on a $107 million bond project for Dumas Independent School District, to which Cactus belongs. It includes a brand-new elementary school for Cactus, in part to accommodate all the recent immigrant children. The bond package is expected to pass.

"The elementary school is a center of pride in this community, a kind of jewel," Funderburg says proudly.

Students at Cactus Texas Elementary gather for morning assembly on Oct. 22.
John Burnett / NPR

One might expect locals to oppose a tax increase to educate migrant kids born thousands of miles away. After all, this is Donald Trump country — he won Moore County by 75%. The president wants fewer low-skilled immigrants like these, who he says compete with Americans for jobs and drive down wages.

But Trump's anti-immigrant rhetoric clashes with economic reality out here in the hardworking Panhandle.

Most of the 3,200 residents of Cactus work at the massive JBS Cactus Beef Plant, located across the highway from the elementary school. It's one of the largest meat processing plants in the nation. Cattle trucks arrive all day and all night; refrigerated trailers depart carrying ribeyes, fajitas and hamburger. The 3,000-plus workforce is overwhelmingly immigrant. The town of aging mobile homes even has its own mosque and halal meat market.

The meatpacker is a magnet for immigrants because of its pay scale as well as the language classes, medical benefits and subsidized housing the company offers. And with a turnover rate of 70%, it is always hiring.

JBS also pays application fees for certain employees seeking U.S. citizenship. On this night, a handful of current and former employees have come to the nearby Cactus Nazarene Ministry Center to prep for the naturalization exam.

"Question No. 9: George Washington was a general in the Vietnam War," says a volunteer instructor. "Nope. Which war?" The students look through their papers for the correct answer.

"The Revolutionary War!"

Workers on the "kill floor" make $15-$20 an hour. The chain moves fast — a single cutter may process 100 carcasses an hour. In a single eight-hour shift, three workers will butcher 2,500 animals.

"It's hard, and it's also dangerous," says Sylvia Hernandez, a U.S. resident from Chihuahua, Mexico, who has worked at JBS for 10 years and is studying for the citizenship test. "The kill floor is covered with blood, suet, fat, water."

In 2006, Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents raided the plant, then owned by Swift & Co., and arrested 300 unauthorized workers. The plant, now owned by JBS — the Brazilian multinational meat processor — says it carefully vets applicants to ensure a legal workforce.

"Historically, first-generation Americans, asylees and refugees have viewed our jobs as unique opportunities to pursue the American dream and provide a better future for their families," JBS says in an emailed statement.

"If I'm a U.S. citizen and I speak English," Hernandez continues, "I'm not going to work there. I'll look for a better opportunity. It's the people who don't speak English who go to work at JBS."

But it's not just the beef plant that attracts immigrants to Moore County, where Cactus is located.

"There's lots of work all over, not just in the plant," says Rodrigo Gallegos, a 20-year JBS employee — "in the feedlots, the ranches, the dairies. There's all kinds of work for people who don't have papers, and for people who have papers."

The unlimited availability of work for non-English speakers who are willing to do hard jobs has changed the character of Moore County, which used to be majority white. Today, it is 80% nonwhite. Bill Knight runs the local Greyhound station and serves as the GOP chairman. While the immigrant workforce is good for selling bus tickets, he says, the fact that some foreign-born workers don't assimilate rubs some old-timers the wrong way.

Moore County Judge Rowdy Rhoades says his county is more multicultural and tolerant than it used to be.
John Burnett / NPR

"The Anglo, let's say, feels like they're not welcome in those Spanish stores because [store employees] are accustomed to speaking to the Spanish in Spanish, and not speakin' to us in English," Knight says.

But Moore County Judge Rowdy Rhoades says they've come a long way from the days when the county seat of Dumas was raw and racist.

"That was our culture," he says. "I know back in the '50s, they had a sign that said, 'Blacks don't let the sun set on you in Dumas, Texas.' "

The huge beef plant has been a magnet for immigrant workers for decades, and most folks have adapted to the diverse population that is now a permanent feature of Moore County, Rhoades says.

"So our world has turned around," he says from his office inside the art deco courthouse.

Rhoades compares learning tolerance to putting on weight.

"You know what, it's kinda like gettin' fat. You don't get fat all at once. You put weight on a little at a time. So you adjust, you change your clothes, you go up a size or two. You notice it, but you adapt."

After all, Rhoades says, if you like steak it's got to come from somewhere.

Copyright 2019 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

AILSA CHANG, HOST:

More than half a million migrant parents and children were taken into custody over the past year as a historic wave of families crossed the southern border. After being released to await their day in immigration court, many of these families head to places where unskilled jobs are plentiful, like at meat processors, dairies and farms. And when these migrants take these jobs, they change the demographics of the area.

NPR's John Burnett takes us to one place undergoing a transformation, a slaughterhouse town in the Texas panhandle.

JOHN BURNETT, BYLINE: It is the 8 o'clock assembly at Cactus Elementary School, located hard on the bleak plains of the Texas panhandle. Kiddos with colorful backpacks and sleepy eyes sit cross-legged on the gym floor while their principal kickstarts the day.

TJ FUNDERBERG: Good morning, Cactus Elementary.

UNIDENTIFIED CROWD #1: Good morning.

BURNETT: Many of these children come from poor villages in faraway lands - Guatemala, Somalia, Myanmar, Congo, Haiti - and they're clearly thrilled to be in school. Principal T.J. Funderberg welcomes them all.

FUNDERBERG: We wouldn't just need a United States map. We need a world map to map where everybody comes from, OK? But we're all here.

BURNETT: Over the past year, student enrollment at Cactus Elementary has surged from 300 to 400 kids. Many of their parents crossed the southern border and made their way to this hardscrabble town. Some have work permits, and some don't.

FUNDERBERG: What we found is the students that come in from Guatemala and even, like, Africa - they may have had some education. Like, in Guatemala, they don't start first grade until 8 or 9 years old. And so we've really kind of had to rethink the way that we do everything.

BURNETT: For instance, they need more English classes and fewer pop quizzes. The school also needs more room. Tomorrow voters will decide on a $107 million bond project for the whole school district. It includes a new elementary school for Cactus, in part to accommodate all the recent immigrant children. The bond package is expected to pass.

You might think locals would oppose a tax increase to educate migrant kids born thousands of miles away. After all, this is Donald Trump country. He won Moore County by 75%. The president wants fewer low-skilled immigrants like these. He says they take Americans' jobs and drive down wages. But Trump's anti-immigrant rhetoric clashes with economic reality out here in the hardworking panhandle of Texas.

(SOUNDBITE OF MACHINERY HUMMING)

BURNETT: That's the sound of the giant JBS Cactus Beef Plant. It's located across the highway from the elementary school, and most of the parents work there. The plant's workforce of 3,000-plus is overwhelmingly immigrant. Cactus even has its own mosque and halal meat market. On this night, a handful of current and former employees have come to the nearby Cactus Nazarene Ministry Center to prep for the U.S. citizenship exam.

UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: No. 9 - George Washington was a general in the Vietnam War.

UNIDENTIFIED CROWD #2: No.

UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: No. Which war?

BURNETT: Sylvia Hernandez, a lawful U.S. resident from Chihuahua, Mexico, has worked at JBS for 10 years now. She says it's the best paycheck around, and they earn it. Workers on the kill floor make 15 to $20 an hour, but the chain moves fast. A single cutter may process a hundred cow carcasses an hour.

SYLVIA HERNANDEZ: (Through interpreter) It's hard, and it's also dangerous. The kill floor is covered with blood, suet, fat, water.

BURNETT: The meat packer is popular with immigrants because of the pay scale, and it offers language classes, medical benefits and subsidized housing. And with a turnover rate of 70%, they're always hiring. In 2006, immigration agents raided the plant, then owned by Swift and Company, and arrested 300 unauthorized workers.

The plant, now owned by JBS, the Brazilian multinational meat processor, says it carefully vets applicants to ensure a legal workforce. JBS says in a statement, historically, first-generation Americans, asylees and refugees have viewed our jobs as unique opportunities to pursue the American dream. Again, Sylvia Hernandez.

HERNANDEZ: (Through interpreter) If I'm a U.S. citizen and I speak English, I'm not going to work there. I'll look for a better opportunity. It's the people who don't speak English who go to work at JBS.

BURNETT: Moore County used to be majority white. Today it's 80% non-white. Bill Knight runs the local Greyhound station and serves as the GOP chairman. While multiculturalism is good for the bus business, he says the fact that some foreign-born workers don't assimilate rubs some old-timers the wrong way.

BILL KNIGHT: The Anglo, let's say, feels like they're not welcome in those Spanish stores because they're accustomed to speaking to the Spanish in Spanish and not speaking us in English.

BURNETT: But Moore County judge Rowdy Rhoades says they've come a long way from the days when the county seat of Dumas was raw and racist.

ROWDY RHOADES: That was our culture. I know back in the '50s that, you know, they had a sign that said, blacks, don't let the sun set on you in Dumas, Texas.

BURNETT: The beef plant has been a magnet for immigrant workers for years, and Rhoades says folks have adapted to the diverse population that is now a permanent feature of Moore County. He compares learning tolerance to putting on weight.

RHOADES: You know what? It's kind of like getting fat. You don't get fat all at once. You put weight on a little bit of time, so you adjust, and you change your clothes. You go up a size or two or - you notice it, but you adapt.

BURNETT: After all, Judge Rhoades says, if you like rib-eyes and hamburgers, they've got to come from somewhere.

John Burnett, NPR News, Cactus, Texas. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.