Our 10 Most-Read Political Stories Of 2019 Reflect A Shifting Capitol Power Dynamic
An overarching and important theme of 2019 was the shifting power dynamic in Washington. The 2018 midterm elections put Democrats in control of the House of Representatives after eight years of Republican control — and made Nancy Pelosi House speaker for the second time in her career.
That had consequences, including the use of the ultimate check on presidential authority, impeachment.
Many of this year's most-read political stories on NPR.org centered on what the newly minted majority Democrats would do and how they'd use their power.
Other major stories of the year include the release of Robert Mueller's report on Russian interference in the 2016 election and the Democratic presidential primary race kicking into high gear.
Stories that just missed the top 10 covered Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg's health, the early 2019 government shutdown, whether President Trump's tax returns would have to be released, severalon the Ukraine affair that led to Trump's impeachment and Trump's Hurricane Dorian Sharpie moment.
Here are the headlines that did make the cut:
10. After Stinging Presidential Loss, Popular Vote Movement Gains Momentum In States
After Hillary Clinton lost in 2016 despite winning the popular vote by some 3 million votes, additional states have pushed for legislation to essentially eliminate the Electoral College.
That isn't likely to happen anytime soon because of states controlled by Republicans, but it's proof of just how much Democrats are smarting since 2000. In two of the three presidential elections that Democrats lost this century, they won the popular vote.
Americans appear conflicted. A Pew Research Center polllast year found that 55% want the Constitution amended so the candidate who receives the most votes wins. But a July NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist pollfound just 42% of Americans thought eliminating the Electoral College was a good idea.
9. Ted Cruz And Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Team Up To Ban Lawmakers From Lobbying
Twitter is not normally a place where people with polarized views find consensus. But it was the platform where it started for two of the most outspoken politicians of this era — liberal Democratic Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York and conservative Republican Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas.
The duo teamed up on legislation that would impose a lifetime ban on members of Congress becoming lobbyists. Not everyone thinks that's such a great idea, because there could be unintended consequences.
No ban has passed since this story got attention. In June, Rep. David Cicilline of Rhode Island introduced a billprohibiting members of Congress from lobbying. But it only had one cosponsor and it went nowhere. As of August, Ocasio-Cortez said her legislative team was in discussion with Cruz's.
Cruz and Ocasio-Cortez looked like they might team up again on making birth control available over the counter, but Ocasio-Cortez balked, saying she wants something done about affordability of birth control, too.
8. FACT CHECK: Trump's Oval Office Pitch For A Border Wall
Trump used his first Oval Office address to try and make the sale on his desired border wall along the U.S.-Mexico border.
NPR fact-checked six of the claims the president made, including that his rhetoric overstates the criminal threat of immigrants and that most of the illegal drugs entering the country go through legal ports of entry that a border wall would not stop.
Trump also said the wall would be paid for "indirectly" by the U.S.-Mexico-Canada trade agreement. That's a far cry from his original campaign claim that Mexico would pay for a wall — the country isn't.
7. Poll: Trump Approval Down, Slips With Base
During the record-long partial government shutdown in January, Trump's approval rating fell to 39% in the NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist poll.
Trump's approval rating has never been above 45% in the NPR poll or below 35% (in August 2017 after his response to the racist violence in Charlottesville, Va.). In the past year, it's been a range of 39% to 44%.
Trump's ratings are historically low on average and seemingly immovable, signaling a potentially brutal 2020 presidential election to come.
6. Democrats Unveil Changes To House Rules On Debt Ceiling, Ethics
With Democrats' takeover of the House in early 2019, it meant not just the dawning of a check on Trump but also a new way of doing business after eight years of GOP control.
A lot of what Democrats implemented was in response to the tense intra- and inter-party fighting of the Boehner years. When Republican John Boehner was speaker, he faced a debt-ceiling crisis because conservative hard-liners looked to force spending cuts. Pelosi moved to make debt-ceiling raises automatic.
She also created a committee to address climate change, revived a rule to give lawmakers 72 hours to read major legislation before they can vote and amended rules on discrimination to allow religious headwear to be worn in the House chamber.
And looking to avoid the coup attempts faced by Boehner, she made it tougher to oust a sitting speaker. Pelosi's tight grip on her caucus would show again in the push to impeach Trump. Just two Democrats — one of whom switched to become a Republican — defied Pelosi and voted against the most significant article of impeachment against Trump, abuse of power.
5. Where Does Illegal Immigration Mostly Occur? Here's What The Data Tell Us
The issue of illegal immigration has been dominated by talk of migrants coming across the nation's southernmost border because of Trump's campaign for a border wall.
But the reality is that most people in the United States illegally didn't cross the border; they came legally and didn't leave.
4. READ: The Mueller Report, With Redactions
The Mueller report on Russian interference in the 2016 election was arguably the most anticipated document of 2019.
That 400-page report noted that while the Justice Department's guidance is not to indict a sitting president, the findings did not "exonerate" Trump.
"The evidence we obtained about the President's actions and intent presents difficult issues that prevent us from conclusively determining that no criminal conduct occurred," the report noted. "Accordingly, while this report does not conclude that the President committed a crime, it also does not exonerate him."
In fact, it found multiple contacts between Trump campaign officials and Russians, that Russia was trying to get Trump elected, and that Trump campaign officials welcomed it. The report also found several potential instances of obstruction of justice committed by the president.
"[T]he Constitution requires a process other than the criminal justice system to formally accuse a sitting president of wrongdoing," Mueller said in a news conference, a month after his report was released.
But that process — impeachment — would not come, as it related to the Mueller report, especially after the special counsel's shaky public testimony in July. After the Ukraine affair, Democrats did consider an obstruction of justice charge,as it relates to the Mueller report, to show a broader pattern from the president, but they ultimately opted against it.
3. FACT CHECK: Trump's State Of The Union Address
This was Trump's first State of the Union address after the Democrats' takeover of the House. But rather than graciously acknowledge the new power dynamic in Washington, like past presidents have, Trump jumped right in.
He touted an "unprecedented economic boom" (it's not), wages that are "rising at the fastest pace in decades" (they aren't) and took credit for unleashing "a revolution in American energy," making the U.S. "now the No. 1 producer of oil and natural gas anywhere in the world" (even though the record fracking expansion predates his time in office).
Trump also warned, "If there is going to be peace and legislation, there cannot be war and investigation."
Obviously, that threat did not stop Democrats from impeaching him.
2. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Releases Green New Deal Outline
Ocasio-Cortez was one of the breakout figures of the 2018 election. She ran as an unabashed and uncompromising progressive who stood for the opposite of Trump.
And her bold Green New Deal, introduced with Massachusetts Sen. Ed Markey, grabbed headlines and attention.
The Green New Deal — as described by NPR's Danielle Kurtzleben — is "a massive policy package that would remake the U.S. economy and, [Ocasio-Cortez and Markey] hope, eliminate all U.S. carbon emissions. That's a really big — potentially impossibly big — undertaking."
Support for the proposal became something of a litmus test for progressives, but its boldness also made it a lightning rod that conservatives have used to target Democrats.
For Democrats, though, especially younger ones, climate change is an increasingly important issue. In the latest NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist poll, climate change is the No. 2 issue for Democrats and tops the list for progressives and Democratic men. (Democratic women picked health care first, with climate not too far behind.)
1. Speaker Pelosi Revokes Vice President Pence's House Office Space
This story highlighted the newfound power of House Democrats.
As a sign of the close relationship between Republican former Speaker Paul Ryan and Vice President Pence, a former congressman from Indiana, Ryan set aside office space for Pence on the House side.
But soon after Pelosi was sworn in, she reversed that.
Vice presidents generally maintain an office on Capitol Hill on the Senate side, given their role technically as president of the Senate. If there's a tie in the Senate, the vice president breaks it.
Pence, in fact, has so far been called on to break ties 13 timesduring the Trump administration, including on the nomination of Education Secretary Betsy DeVos, to begin debate on repealing the health care law and on a bill to give states permission to withhold federal family planning fundsfrom Planned Parenthood.
Life in the minority in the House is tough. The majority rules — and makes them, and this showed that in a very tangible way.
Copyright 2023 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.