U.S. Has Deployed New, Small Nukes On Submarine, According To Group

Jan 29, 2020
Originally published on January 30, 2020 7:52 am

The U.S. has begun deploying a new type of low-yield nuclear warhead aboard some ballistic missile submarines, according to a report by an independent monitor.

When the USS Tennessee, an Ohio-class submarine, went on patrol in the final weeks of 2019, it carried "one or two" of the new weapons, according to a post by the Federation of American Scientists.

"It is apparently still out there now and expected to come back sometime in February," says Hans Kristensen, director of the group's nuclear information project. He believes a second submarine carrying the weapon may also be patrolling in the Pacific.

Kristensen says the assessment is based on conversations with government officials, who have spoken to the group about the weapon's deployment.

The Pentagon officially declined to comment on the report: "It is U.S. policy to neither confirm nor deny the presence or absence of nuclear weapons at any general or specific location, as such, we cannot confirm or deny this reporting at this time," it said in a written statement to NPR.

The warheads were produced by the Department of Energy over the past year. An Energy Department spokesperson confirmed to NPR in November that they had been transferred to the U.S. Navy.

The weapon is known as the W76-2, and it appears superficially identical to the much more powerful W76-1 nuclear weapons carried by the same submarines. But unlike those thermonuclear whoppers, the W76-2 has a relatively "small" yield of perhaps, 5 kilotons — or about one-third the size of the Hiroshima bomb, according to Kristensen. It was developed in response to the Trump Administration's Nuclear Posture Review, which outlined the need for smaller nukes.

Much of that need centers around Russia, which the administration says is preparing to use small nukes in a conflict. The idea is that Russia would use relatively low-yield nuclear weapon to get a superior adversary such as the U.S. or NATO to back down in a conflict, according to Katarzyna Zysk, who studies Russian military doctrine at the Norwegian Institute for Defence Studies in Oslo.

Zysk says that Russia has made a number of vague statements about nuclear use recently, while deploying several systems that are capable of carrying smaller "tactical" nuclear weapons. Deploying a weapon such as the W76-2 undermines any Russian strategy of using small nukes in a conflict, she says, because it gives the U.S. a way to respond without rolling out the big ones. "That's the simple logic," she says.

But critics warn that the strategy carries huge risks. For one thing, there is no way for a potential adversary to tell the difference between the launch of a ballistic missile tipped with a low-yield warhead and one carrying a "large" warhead. The Russians, monitoring U.S. launches, could easily confuse the two.

Perhaps the greater risk, Kristensen warns, is that a tit-for-tat exchange of small nuclear weapons could lead to a larger nuclear war. "Once you start popping nukes, the bets are off," he says.

Copyright 2020 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

NOEL KING, HOST:

The U.S. has started to deploy smaller nuclear weapons on some of its submarines according to a new report. Some people worry this could make a nuclear war more likely. Here's NPR's Geoff Brumfiel.

GEOFF BRUMFIEL, BYLINE: The new weapon is believed to be relatively small, capable of leveling several city blocks instead of the whole city. According to the Federation of American Scientists, an independent watchdog, this little nuke was loaded onto a missile submarine late last year and sent out into the Atlantic Ocean on patrol. The Pentagon declined to comment about the new system. What's behind this weapon? In a word, it's Russia.

KATARZYNA ZYSK: Russia maintains an option to use the nuclear weapons primarily politically, which means to intimidate.

BRUMFIEL: Katarzyna Zysk is with the Norwegian Institute for Defence Studies in Oslo. She says if Russia was under extreme threat by the West, it might fire off a small nuclear weapon to get the U.S. or NATO to back down. The best way to stop Russia from doing that - build your own small nuclear weapon to undermine the plan.

ZYSK: That's the simple logic.

BRUMFIEL: Critics like Hans Kristensen, with the Federation of American Scientists, worry all these small nukes could lead to big trouble.

HANS KRISTENSEN: The big illusion with this weapon that I think people are arguing - well, it's just a little one; you know, we're just doing for deterrence purposes.

BRUMFIEL: But Kristensen worries in the real world, these less destructive nukes might get used. If that happens, who knows what would come next?

KRISTENSEN: Once you start popping nukes, the bets are off.

BRUMFIEL: And the big doomsday bombs are more likely to get used.

Geoff Brumfiel, NPR News, Washington.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC) Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.